Nominations Clarifications Post #5
Jun. 9th, 2019 03:47 pm![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
General
All nominations have been approved except for the ones in this post.
Tagset here.
You can find the Fandom Wrangling results here.
If you have any questions, or see a wandering tag, go ahead and comment or email rareexmod@gmail.com
Questions
There are questions for the following fandoms:
Crossover Fandom
Game of Thrones (TV)
Midsomer Murders – All Media Types
Sān guó yǎn yì | Romance of the Three Kingdoms - All Media Types
Star Wars – All Media Types
1) Crossover Fandom
"Ethan Hunt/Max Rockatansky"
This was not disambiguated. Do you mean the Ethan Hunt of the Mission Impossible movies and the Max Rockatansky of the Mad Max films? I’ll amend it to that if there’s no reply by Monday June 10th at 11:59 PM EST.
2) Game of Thrones (TV)
"Arianne Martell/Arya Stark"
"Arianne Martell/Sansa Stark"
"Arya Stark/Willas Tyrell"
To my knowledge, Arianne Martell and Willas Tyrell exist only in the A Song of Ice and Fire books. Do you prefer they be added to those books or did you want the show versions of Arya and Sansa with them? In that case, I will add them under Crossover Fandom. If there’s no reply by Monday June 10th at 11:59 PM EST, I'll add it under the books.
3) Midsomer Murders – All Media Types
"Tom Barnaby/Gavin Troy"
It seems AO3 has marged the Midsomer Murders television show with the Chief Inspector Barnaby books by Caroline Graham. Is this nomination for the TV series or the Caroline Graham books? If there’s no reply by Monday June 10th at 11:59 PM EST, I’ll change the fandom tag to the show.
4) Sān guó yǎn yì | Romance of the Three Kingdoms - All Media Types
"Dǒng Zhuó/Lǚ Bù"
There seem to be various versions, a novel and tv shows; nominator, are you partial to a specific one? If there’s no reply by Monday June 10th at 11:59 PM EST, I'll amend it to "Sān guó yǎn yì | Romance of the Three Kingdoms - Luó Guànzhōng".
5) Star Wars - All Media Types
Star Wars ships in the tagset will appear as laid out in the Fandom Wrangling results. Unless there’s a reply stating a preference where there is ambiguity, as in the case of ships with characters who appear in the books and comics as well as in the films, by Monday June 10th at 11:59 PM EST, I will divide the ships according to the aforementioned post.
All nominations have been approved except for the ones in this post.
Tagset here.
You can find the Fandom Wrangling results here.
If you have any questions, or see a wandering tag, go ahead and comment or email rareexmod@gmail.com
Questions
There are questions for the following fandoms:
Crossover Fandom
Game of Thrones (TV)
Midsomer Murders – All Media Types
Sān guó yǎn yì | Romance of the Three Kingdoms - All Media Types
Star Wars – All Media Types
1) Crossover Fandom
"Ethan Hunt/Max Rockatansky"
This was not disambiguated. Do you mean the Ethan Hunt of the Mission Impossible movies and the Max Rockatansky of the Mad Max films? I’ll amend it to that if there’s no reply by Monday June 10th at 11:59 PM EST.
2) Game of Thrones (TV)
"Arianne Martell/Arya Stark"
"Arianne Martell/Sansa Stark"
"Arya Stark/Willas Tyrell"
To my knowledge, Arianne Martell and Willas Tyrell exist only in the A Song of Ice and Fire books. Do you prefer they be added to those books or did you want the show versions of Arya and Sansa with them? In that case, I will add them under Crossover Fandom. If there’s no reply by Monday June 10th at 11:59 PM EST, I'll add it under the books.
3) Midsomer Murders – All Media Types
"Tom Barnaby/Gavin Troy"
It seems AO3 has marged the Midsomer Murders television show with the Chief Inspector Barnaby books by Caroline Graham. Is this nomination for the TV series or the Caroline Graham books? If there’s no reply by Monday June 10th at 11:59 PM EST, I’ll change the fandom tag to the show.
4) Sān guó yǎn yì | Romance of the Three Kingdoms - All Media Types
"Dǒng Zhuó/Lǚ Bù"
There seem to be various versions, a novel and tv shows; nominator, are you partial to a specific one? If there’s no reply by Monday June 10th at 11:59 PM EST, I'll amend it to "Sān guó yǎn yì | Romance of the Three Kingdoms - Luó Guànzhōng".
5) Star Wars - All Media Types
Star Wars ships in the tagset will appear as laid out in the Fandom Wrangling results. Unless there’s a reply stating a preference where there is ambiguity, as in the case of ships with characters who appear in the books and comics as well as in the films, by Monday June 10th at 11:59 PM EST, I will divide the ships according to the aforementioned post.