Nominations Clarifications Post #3
Jun. 6th, 2019 01:15 am![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
rareexmod posting in ![[community profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/community.png){kind=small}
rarepairsexchangeGeneral:
Please disambiguate ship tags for anything nominated under “Crossover Fandom” and any other fandom with characters who appear in other fandoms, such as for example ships in Star Wars or Tolkien fandoms.
Please do not nominate “All Media Types” or “& Related Fandoms”. If you feel one of those is the most suitable tag, please comment or email to explain.
From this point on all clarifications have 24 hours. Everything currently waiting has 24 hours regardless of when it was posted. After that I will determine a course of action. That time for this post will be 1:15 AM EST.
You can find the Fandom Wrangling results here.
More detailed nominations instructions here.
Tagset here.
If you have any questions, or see a wandering tag, go ahead and comment or email rareexmod@gmail.com
Questions:
There are questions relevant to the following fandoms:
Final Fantasy XV
Marvel Cinematic Universe
Les Misérables
Dangan Ronpa
Le Fantôme de l'Opéra | Phantom of the Opera
Bishoujo Senshi Sailor Moon | Pretty Sailor Guardian
Bionicle - All Media Types
Ivanhoe - All Media Types
Overlord - Maruyama Kugane & Related Fandoms
Wiedźmin | The Witcher - All Media Types
1) Final Fantasy XV
“Gladiolus Amicitia/Prompto Argentum/Noctis Lucis Caelum/Ignis Scientia”
This ship is at 211 works once the parameters are applied. Is there any further information that would mean it was eligible? It will be rejected otherwise. If there’s no response by 24 hours after this post, it will be rejected. That time will be 1:15 AM EST.
2) Marvel Cinematic Universe
“Peter Quill/Wade Wilson”
This ship belongs under “Crossover Fandom”. Which Wade Wilson do you want? If there's no response by 24 hours after this post it will be changed to "Peter Quill (MCU)/Wade Wilson (Deadpool Movies)" and moved to the crossover section. That time will be 1:15 AM EST.
"Victor Creed/Darcy Lewis"
"Victor Creed/Wanda Maximoff"
Victor Creed is not in the MCU. These belong under “Crossover Fandom”. Do you mean the “X-Men (Movieverse)” Victor Creed or another? If there’s no response by 24 hours after this post they will be disambiguated as crossover ships before being moved to that section. That time will be 1:15 AM EST.
3) Les Misérables - All Media Types
“Courfeyrac/Marius Pontmercy”
“Joly/Bossuet Laigle”
“Marius Pontmercy/Éponine Thénardier”
As per the guidelines, All Media Types fandoms are, preferably, to be avoided. Can these ships be nominated under the book, the 2012 movie, the musical, or one of the other adaptations? If there’s no response by 24 hours after this post, it will be changed to the book. That time will be 1:15 AM EST. - amended to various book and movie ships, thank you nominator!
4) Dangan Ronpa - All Media Types
“Hagakure Yasuhiro/Kuwata Leon/Togami Byakuya”
“Izayoi Sonosuke/Kimura Seiko”
“Souda Kazuichi/Tanaka Gundam”
As per the guidelines, All Media Types fandoms are, preferably, to be avoided. Could these ships be nominated under “Danganronpa - Hope's Peak Arc” and/or Danganronpa V3? Are there any other alternatives? If there’s no response by 24 hours after this post, I'll sort it out. That time will be 1:15 AM EST. - amended to Hope's Peak Arc, thank you nominator!
5) Le Fantôme de l'Opéra | Phantom of the Opera & Related Fandoms
“Christine Daaé/Carlotta Giudicelli”
“Christine Daaé/Meg Giry”
“Erik | Phantom of the Opera/Madame Giry”
As per the guidelines, All Media Types fandoms are, preferably, to be avoided. Can these ships be nominated under the book, the 2004 movie, the Andrew Lloyd Webber musical adaptation, or one of the other adaptations? If there’s no response by 24 hours after this post, it will be changed to the afore-mentioned musical. That time will be 1:15 AM EST. - amended to the 2004 movie, thank you nominator!
6) Bishoujo Senshi Sailor Moon | Pretty Sailor Guardian
If someone wants to request a megafandom which could refer to any one specific adaptation of the same story and characters, they would have to be okay with receiving a work for any version of that fandom. No DNWs related to specific versions of Sailor Moon could be enforced: they could get the 90s anime, the manga, Crystal, the live-action show, or the musicals.
I would also like to make clear that even if canonical AO3 tags aren't clear or don't exist, specific canons can be nominated. The tagset is not limited only to fandoms which already have AO3 tags. They can be nominated; or, since this one was already accepted, I could add the fandom tags so that no one who already nominated Sailor Moon but would rather have a more specific fandom need give up a slot--if those specific tags are wanted. The offer is good until 24 hours after this post; if a more specific tag is wanted later it will require a fandom slot. That time will be 1:15 AM EST.
7) Bionicle - All Media Types
This seems to be one story told across various media, but with two versions: Generation 1 and Generation 2, with the second being a reboot. It seems “Hewkii/Macku” are characters from the first. I am willing to add a tag for that version specifically, if the nominator wishes it, so that they would not have to nominate again; otherwise, unless new information comes to light, it seems like this ship only has the one version and would be unaffected by this tag being “All Media Types”. The offer is good until 24 hours after this post; if a more specific tag is wanted later it will require a fandom slot. That time will be 1:15 AM EST.
8) Ivanhoe - All Media Types
This seems to be one book and many adaptations of same. Anyone requesting it would have to be fine with receiving a work created for any of the various versions of the story; no DNWs concerning entire versions of the story would be enforced. As it’s already approved, I am willing to add specific fandom tags and add the ships, so that no one who has nominated this will lose a slot—if those specific tags are wanted. The offer is good until 24 hours after this post; if a more specific tag is wanted later it will require a fandom slot. That time will be 1:15 AM EST.
9) Overlord - Maruyama Kugane & Related Fandoms
This seems to be a novel series with manga and anime adaptatios. Anyone requesting it would have to be fine with receiving a work created for any of the various versions of the story; no DNWs concerning entire versions of the story would be enforced. As it’s already approved, I am willing to add specific fandom tags and add the ships, so that no one who has nominated this will lose a slot—if those specific tags are wanted. The offer is good until 24 hours after this post; if a more specific tag is wanted later it will require a fandom slot. That time will be 1:15 AM EST.
10) Wiedźmin | The Witcher - All Media Types
As "All Media Types" is a tag that covers multiple adaptations of the same source material, I must advise that no DNW concerning an entire version of that story could be enforced; otherwise someone who might only be able to write one canon would face an unfair burden. Those who request with this tag would have to be fine with receiving something for the books, the comics, the video games, the board game, the film, the show, or the card game.
Since this tag has been accepted, I would be willing to add more specific fandom tags myself, so that no one who has already nominated their ships for this need give up another fandom slot--if those specific tags are wanted. I would also be willing to move any book/game/other crossover ships into the crossover fandom, if a list were provided with the disambiguations for each character. The offer is good until 24 hours after this post; if a more specific tag is wanted later it will require a fandom slot. That time will be 1:15 AM EST.
Please disambiguate ship tags for anything nominated under “Crossover Fandom” and any other fandom with characters who appear in other fandoms, such as for example ships in Star Wars or Tolkien fandoms.
Please do not nominate “All Media Types” or “& Related Fandoms”. If you feel one of those is the most suitable tag, please comment or email to explain.
From this point on all clarifications have 24 hours. Everything currently waiting has 24 hours regardless of when it was posted. After that I will determine a course of action. That time for this post will be 1:15 AM EST.
You can find the Fandom Wrangling results here.
More detailed nominations instructions here.
Tagset here.
If you have any questions, or see a wandering tag, go ahead and comment or email rareexmod@gmail.com
Questions:
There are questions relevant to the following fandoms:
Final Fantasy XV
Marvel Cinematic Universe
Les Misérables
Dangan Ronpa
Le Fantôme de l'Opéra | Phantom of the Opera
Bishoujo Senshi Sailor Moon | Pretty Sailor Guardian
Bionicle - All Media Types
Ivanhoe - All Media Types
Overlord - Maruyama Kugane & Related Fandoms
Wiedźmin | The Witcher - All Media Types
1) Final Fantasy XV
“Gladiolus Amicitia/Prompto Argentum/Noctis Lucis Caelum/Ignis Scientia”
This ship is at 211 works once the parameters are applied. Is there any further information that would mean it was eligible? It will be rejected otherwise. If there’s no response by 24 hours after this post, it will be rejected. That time will be 1:15 AM EST.
2) Marvel Cinematic Universe
“Peter Quill/Wade Wilson”
This ship belongs under “Crossover Fandom”. Which Wade Wilson do you want? If there's no response by 24 hours after this post it will be changed to "Peter Quill (MCU)/Wade Wilson (Deadpool Movies)" and moved to the crossover section. That time will be 1:15 AM EST.
"Victor Creed/Darcy Lewis"
"Victor Creed/Wanda Maximoff"
Victor Creed is not in the MCU. These belong under “Crossover Fandom”. Do you mean the “X-Men (Movieverse)” Victor Creed or another? If there’s no response by 24 hours after this post they will be disambiguated as crossover ships before being moved to that section. That time will be 1:15 AM EST.
3) Les Misérables - All Media Types
“Courfeyrac/Marius Pontmercy”
“Joly/Bossuet Laigle”
“Marius Pontmercy/Éponine Thénardier”
As per the guidelines, All Media Types fandoms are, preferably, to be avoided. Can these ships be nominated under the book, the 2012 movie, the musical, or one of the other adaptations? If there’s no response by 24 hours after this post, it will be changed to the book. That time will be 1:15 AM EST. - amended to various book and movie ships, thank you nominator!
4) Dangan Ronpa - All Media Types
“Hagakure Yasuhiro/Kuwata Leon/Togami Byakuya”
“Izayoi Sonosuke/Kimura Seiko”
“Souda Kazuichi/Tanaka Gundam”
As per the guidelines, All Media Types fandoms are, preferably, to be avoided. Could these ships be nominated under “Danganronpa - Hope's Peak Arc” and/or Danganronpa V3? Are there any other alternatives? If there’s no response by 24 hours after this post, I'll sort it out. That time will be 1:15 AM EST. - amended to Hope's Peak Arc, thank you nominator!
5) Le Fantôme de l'Opéra | Phantom of the Opera & Related Fandoms
“Christine Daaé/Carlotta Giudicelli”
“Christine Daaé/Meg Giry”
“Erik | Phantom of the Opera/Madame Giry”
As per the guidelines, All Media Types fandoms are, preferably, to be avoided. Can these ships be nominated under the book, the 2004 movie, the Andrew Lloyd Webber musical adaptation, or one of the other adaptations? If there’s no response by 24 hours after this post, it will be changed to the afore-mentioned musical. That time will be 1:15 AM EST. - amended to the 2004 movie, thank you nominator!
6) Bishoujo Senshi Sailor Moon | Pretty Sailor Guardian
If someone wants to request a megafandom which could refer to any one specific adaptation of the same story and characters, they would have to be okay with receiving a work for any version of that fandom. No DNWs related to specific versions of Sailor Moon could be enforced: they could get the 90s anime, the manga, Crystal, the live-action show, or the musicals.
I would also like to make clear that even if canonical AO3 tags aren't clear or don't exist, specific canons can be nominated. The tagset is not limited only to fandoms which already have AO3 tags. They can be nominated; or, since this one was already accepted, I could add the fandom tags so that no one who already nominated Sailor Moon but would rather have a more specific fandom need give up a slot--if those specific tags are wanted. The offer is good until 24 hours after this post; if a more specific tag is wanted later it will require a fandom slot. That time will be 1:15 AM EST.
7) Bionicle - All Media Types
This seems to be one story told across various media, but with two versions: Generation 1 and Generation 2, with the second being a reboot. It seems “Hewkii/Macku” are characters from the first. I am willing to add a tag for that version specifically, if the nominator wishes it, so that they would not have to nominate again; otherwise, unless new information comes to light, it seems like this ship only has the one version and would be unaffected by this tag being “All Media Types”. The offer is good until 24 hours after this post; if a more specific tag is wanted later it will require a fandom slot. That time will be 1:15 AM EST.
8) Ivanhoe - All Media Types
This seems to be one book and many adaptations of same. Anyone requesting it would have to be fine with receiving a work created for any of the various versions of the story; no DNWs concerning entire versions of the story would be enforced. As it’s already approved, I am willing to add specific fandom tags and add the ships, so that no one who has nominated this will lose a slot—if those specific tags are wanted. The offer is good until 24 hours after this post; if a more specific tag is wanted later it will require a fandom slot. That time will be 1:15 AM EST.
9) Overlord - Maruyama Kugane & Related Fandoms
This seems to be a novel series with manga and anime adaptatios. Anyone requesting it would have to be fine with receiving a work created for any of the various versions of the story; no DNWs concerning entire versions of the story would be enforced. As it’s already approved, I am willing to add specific fandom tags and add the ships, so that no one who has nominated this will lose a slot—if those specific tags are wanted. The offer is good until 24 hours after this post; if a more specific tag is wanted later it will require a fandom slot. That time will be 1:15 AM EST.
10) Wiedźmin | The Witcher - All Media Types
As "All Media Types" is a tag that covers multiple adaptations of the same source material, I must advise that no DNW concerning an entire version of that story could be enforced; otherwise someone who might only be able to write one canon would face an unfair burden. Those who request with this tag would have to be fine with receiving something for the books, the comics, the video games, the board game, the film, the show, or the card game.
Since this tag has been accepted, I would be willing to add more specific fandom tags myself, so that no one who has already nominated their ships for this need give up another fandom slot--if those specific tags are wanted. I would also be willing to move any book/game/other crossover ships into the crossover fandom, if a list were provided with the disambiguations for each character. The offer is good until 24 hours after this post; if a more specific tag is wanted later it will require a fandom slot. That time will be 1:15 AM EST.
