Nominations Queries Post #2

[rareexmod]

General

Nominations are open until May 22 at 11:59 PM EST.

Tagset here.

If you have any questions, or see a wandering tag, go ahead and comment or email rareexmod@gmail.com

Queries

Crossover Fandom
Zarana (G.I. Joe)/Eric Raymond (Jem and the Holograms cartoon)

Which G.I. Joe? There are a couple of cartoons and a movie. If there is no response by 24 hours after this post goes up, one of the cartoons will be chosen.

Daniel Jackson (Stargate SG1)/Elizabeth Bennet (Pride and Prejudice)

Which Elizabeth would you prefer? The book, or one of the adaptations? If there is no response by 24 hours after this post goes up, the book version will be chosen.

Diplomat’s Son (song)
Diplomat’s Son/Best Friend

Is this fandom "Diplomat's Son - Vampire Weekend (Song)"? If so, the fandom nomination is fine as is, but would the nominator like a change to include the artist name? If there's no response by 24 hours after this post goes up, the tag will be accepted without change. ETA: Upon further reflection, the tag was changed and approved. If different song was intended, nominator, please let us know and we will add it so that you won't need another slot.

Dragon Age - All Media Types
Cullen Rutherford/Dorian Pavus/The Iron Bull (DA)
Dorian Pavus/Fenris (DA)
Dorian Pavus/Male Trevelyan (DA)

Dragon Age (Video Games)
Anora Mac Tir/Celene Valmont (DA Games)
Ashaad/Saemus Dumar (DA Games)
Female Cadash/Raleigh Samson (DA Games)
Female Hawke/Meredith Stannard (DA Games)
Gamlen Amell/Raleigh Samson (DA Games)
Jowan/Female Surana (DA Games)
Jowan/Lily/Female Surana (DA Games)
Loghain Mac Tir/Morrigan (DA Games)
Male Cadash/Dorian Pavus (DA Games)
Male Cadash/Raleigh Samson (DA Games)
Raleigh Samson/Ser Thrask (DA Games)
Zevran Arainai/Female Surana (DA Games)

Which of these is the preferred fandom for Dragon Age nominators? If there's no response 24 hours after this post has gone up, we will choose All Media Types.

W.I.T.C.H.
Caleb/Will Vandom
Cornelia Hale/Irma Lair

Would these ships be cartoon or the comics W.I.T.C.H.? If there is no response by 24 hours after this post goes up, the cartoon will be chosen.

陈情令 | The Untamed (TV) RPF
Jiang Cheng/Jin GuangYao (The Untamed TV)

The fandom is for RPF, but the ship is disambiguated for the show; is this ship for the show or RPF of the show's cast? If there is no response by 24 hours after this post goes up, the fandom will be changed to the show.

Comments

[cypher]

Not the nominator, but the Untamed one is for characters, not actors; that ship belongs to the show.

[rareexmod]

Thank you for this information!

W.I.T.C.H.

[(Anonymous)]

Caleb/Will Vandom (Cartoon)
Cornelia Hale/Irma Lair (Comics)
Thank you for asking!

Re: W.I.T.C.H.

[rareexmod]

We can't split one fandom in the interface that way I'm afraid. We can only change the fandom once. But we can add the version yours isn't changed to separately, so we'll do that.

[(Anonymous)]

Diplomat’s Son (song)

Not the nominator but please consider changing to include the artist anyway to prevent confusion later.

[(Anonymous)]

+1

[rareexmod]

Thank you (and the anon below) for your input! After some thought, we will change it if we get no response.

[(Anonymous)]

Nominator here, apologies for responding late. The fandom tag is great, but the ship tag has Diplomat’s Song instead of Diplomat’s Son (Song).

[rareexmod]

Thank you! It's been fixed.

[southerncontinentskies]

Dragon Age - AMT nominator here. I don't feel strongly about AMT vs Video Games, so if the Video Games nominator does, I wouldn't object to switching. I chose AMT primarily because from what I've seen it's the most common exchange choice.

[rareexmod]

Thank you! We will see if there's another response; if there's none, would you still want your nominations to be changed?

[southerncontinentskies]

Actually on reflection, I think unless the Video Games nominator does feel strongly, AMT is the better choice. There are a few comics/other non-game sources that flesh out some very minor characters that people might conceivably want to nominate, and if we go with Video Games here, those hypothetical nominators would have to use a separate, more specific fandom.

[rareexmod]

Thank you! We'll go with that.

[hiddencait]

For Daniel Jackson (Stargate SG1)/Elizabeth Bennet (Pride and Prejudice) - the one I would prefer is Pride and Prejudice (2005) thanks! Sorry about that - I'm usually better about catching it.

[rareexmod]

Thank you! It's been changed and approved.

[desertvixen]

For G.I. Joe it is the 1980s cartoon. Sorry, in all the times it's been nommed before, no one's ever asked!

[rareexmod]

Thank you! It's already been approved to say the cartoon; does that work for you?

[(Anonymous)]

Yes that works for me. - desertvixen

[(Anonymous)]

Hi! As per usual, none of my "Crossover Fandom" selections like to stay put, hah. I don't know why they always do this for every exchanges I put the in for. I think they might be cursed.

Lucifer TV and Supernatural:
-Castiel (Supernatural)/Lucifer Morningstar (Lucifer TV)
-Lucifer (Supernatural)/Lucifer Morningstar (Lucifer TV)

Need to be in Crossover Fandom. They're both in the above fandoms listed. Thank you so much!

~K

[rareexmod]

Thank you! We'll find another disambiguation for them.

[rareexmod]

They should now appear under Crossover Fandom like this:
Castiel (Supernatural TV)/Lucifer Morningstar (Lucifer Netflix)
Lucifer (Supernatural TV)/Lucifer Morningstar (Lucifer Netflix)

[(Anonymous)]

Awesome! Ty!! I’ll use this for future exchanges too. Hopefully Satan can stop being an Imp long enough to stay put.

~K

[rareexmod]

No problem! And here's hoping!