Nominations Clarifications Post #2

[rareexmod]

General

Nominations are open until May 30 at 11:59 PM EST.

Tagset here.

If you have any questions, or see a wandering tag, go ahead and comment or email rareexmod@gmail.com


Questions

Some of these remained unanswered in the last post, and some of these are new.

Arrowverse
Artemis Crock/Wally West (Arrowverse)

Nora Allen/Jaime Reyes (Arrowverse)

Artemis Crock and Jaime Reyes do not seem to have appeared in Arrowverse. Nominator, please move to Crossover Fandom with both canons in disambiguations or explain if we have missed something.

Astra/Alex Danvers (Arrowverse)

This ship has 356 works after the filters have been applied. We will be rejecting it in twenty-four hours.

Bishoujo Senshi Sailor Moon | Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon - We will accept 90s anime, Crystal & Manga, or live-action.

Crossover Fandom
Usagi Tsukino (Sailor Moon)/ Zetsu (Naruto) - Which version of Usagi?
Peggy Carter (Agent Carter)/Diana (Wonder Woman) - Which version of Diana?

Dangan Ronpa - All Media Types
Dangan Ronpa: Trigger Happy Havoc
We would like feedback on whether or not to separate out the Hope's Peak Arc, of which Trigger Happy Havoc is a part. V3 would be separate no matter what. We will not be accepting Dangan Ronpa - All Media Types.

Dragon Age - All Media Types
Alistair/Female Brosca (Dragon Age)
Alistair/Female Mahariel (Dragon Age)
Alistair/Female Surana (Dragon Age)
Alistair/Female Trevelyan (Dragon Age)
Female Adaar/Cullen Rutherford
Female Aeducan/Alistair (Dragon Age)
Female Cadash/Cullen Rutherford
Female Inquisitor/Varric Tethras
Solas/Female Trevelyan (Dragon Age)

Dragon Age (Video Games)
Alistair/Female Hawke
Alistair/Morrigan (Dragon Age)
Ameridan/Colette (Dragon Age)
Ameridan/Kordillus Drakon (Dragon Age)
Ameridan/Telana (Dragon Age)
Anora Mac Tir/Female Warden
Blackwall/Female Inquisitor
Dagna/Lace Harding (Dragon Age)
Dagna/Lace Harding/Sera (Dragon Age)
Dagna/Sera (Dragon Age)
Dorian Pavus/Felix Alexius (Dragon Age (Video Games))
Female Hawke/Cullen Rutherford
Female Hawke/Merrill (Dragon Age)
Female Inquisitor/Sera
Hawke/Merrill
Isabela/Aveline Vallen
Isabela/Cullen Rutherford
Josephine Montilyet/Female Trevelyan (Dragon Age)
Josephine Montilyet/Sera
Lace Harding/Bram Kenric (Dragon Age)
Lace Harding/Sera (Dragon Age)
Loghain Mac Tir/Morrigan
Male Hawke/Varric Tethras (Dragon Age (Video Games))
Male Inquisitor/Varric Tethras (Dragon Age (Video Games))
Orsino/Meredith Stannard
Regalyan D'Marcall/Cassandra Pentaghast

Dragon Age: Inquisition
Calpernia/Raleigh Samson (DA:I)
Cremisius "Krem" Aclassi/Female Inquisitor (DA:I)
Cremisius "Krem" Aclassi/Lace Harding (DA:I)
Cremisius "Krem" Aclassi/Male Inquisitor (DA:I)
Desire Demon(s)/Female Inquisitor (DA:I)
Female Adaar/Blackwall | Thom Rainier (DA:I)
Female Adaar/Female Cadash (DA:I)
Female Adaar/Female Lavellan (DA:I)
Female Adaar/Josephine Montilyet (DA:I)
Female Adaar/Lace Harding (DA:I)
Female Adaar/Male Cadash (DA:I)
Female Cadash/Lace Harding (DA:I)
Florianne de Chalons/Livius Erimond (DA:I)
Imshael/Female Inquisitor (DA:I)
Imshael/Male Inquisitor (DA:I)
Male Cadash/Dorian Pavus (DA:I)

Dragon Age: Origins
Ariane/Finn (DA:O)
Female Aeducan/Anora Mac Tir (DA:O)
Female Aeducan/Female Brosca (DA:O)
Female Aeducan/Female Cousland (DA:O)
Female Aeducan/Pyral Harrowmont (DA:O)
Female Amell/Female Surana (DA:O)
Female Mahariel/Female Tabris (DA:O)
Feynriel/Jowan (DA:O)
Finn/Surana (DA:O)
Jowan/Desire Demon (DA:O)
Jowan/Female Surana (DA:O)
Jowan/Lily (DA:O)
Jowan/Lily/Surana (DA:O)
Jowan/Male Surana (DA:O)
Jowan/Merrill (DA:O)
Loghain Mac Tir/Wynne (DA:O)
Sten/Female Surana (DA:O)
Zevran Arainai/Female Brosca (DA:O)
Zevran Arainai/Female Surana (DA:O)

Dragon Age nominators, how would you like us to proceed? Merged into All Media Types, merged into Video Games, or separated by installment?

Formula 1 RPF
Kimi Räikkönen/Sebastian Vettel

This ship has 291 works after the filters have been applied. We will be rejecting it in twenty-four hours.

Harry Potter - J. K. Rowling
Hermione Granger/Bellatrix Black Lestrange (HP)

This ship has 279 works after the filters have been applied. We will be rejecting it in twenty-four hours.

The Hobbit (Jackson Movies)
Dís/Belladonna Took
Sigrid/Tauriel (Hobbit Movies)

Did Dís and Sigrid appear in the movies?

Marvel Cinematic Universe
Loki/Steve Rogers (MarvCinUni)

This ship has 419 works after the filters have been applied. We will be rejecting it in twenty-four hours.

Star Wars Legends: Outbound Flight - Timothy Zahn
The Daughter | Winged Goddess/Ahsoka Tano
The Son | Fanged God/Ahsoka Tano

Did you intend to nominate this under "Star Wars: The Clone Wars (2008) - All Media Types" instead? That is where the characters appear.

Comments

[aearis]

I'm for merging Dragon Age into Dragon Age (Video Games) rather than individual games since a lot of the characters show up in more than one game. I'd be okay with AMT too, but I just thought I'd mention I've already nominated Dragon Age: Magekiller separately. It's a comic, and only one of the characters in the nominated relationship appears in the games, so it could potentially be merged into AMT but not Video Games.

[venatohru]

I don't feel strongly against merging them! But my thinking when I nominated Origins and Inquisition separately rather than under the AMT or video games umbrella was that someone who'd only played Origins could potentially want to request, for example, Morrigan/Leliana and then get matched with someone who offered them but had only played Inquisition (or vice versa). Hope that makes sense!

[rareexmod]

Thank you! After giving it thought, we have decided to merge the games.

[rareexmod]

Thank you! We have accepted the comic separately and merged the rest.

[igrockspock]

Hello! I noticed that in Star Trek Picard, Laris/Zhaban is included in the tag set twice, once with PIC as the fandom and once with Star Trek as the fandom. I can see how that could cause matching confusion, so I wanted to let you know.

[rareexmod]

Thank you! The one with Star Trek as the fandom has been removed.

[(Anonymous)]

My opinion on Dangan Ronpa is to go the Hope's Peak Arc umbrella route instead of separating individual games! A lot of characters between games (plus the DR3 anime) canonically end up interacting/their stories end up intersecting, so even though nominations are almost closed for the round, in the future, it could potentially mean some particularly-rare but canonically plausible rarepairs for the series would be easier to sort.

[rareexmod]

We have gone with your suggestion. Thank you!

[artabria]

Hi! The W.I.T.C.H. Comics nominations are under the Uncategorized Fandoms instead of "Cartoons & Comics & Graphic Novels".

[rareexmod]

Hello! This is due to how the fandom is wrangled on AO3. The current canonical tag is used for the comics and the cartoon, and there is no separate one for the comics. For the purposes of the exchange, the tagset does separate them, so that people may request and offer the specific version they would want. AO3 hasn't categorized it, so it shows up in there rather than the Comics category. That may change in the future, but it's not within the control of an exchange mod.

[artabria]

Okay! And thanks for the quick answer, :D